In the heart of Ohio’s Amish Country, a collection of pie shops stands as a testament to enduring traditions and local flavors. These bakeries, cherished by locals and barely on the radar of outside visitors, offer a glimpse into the world of Amish baking that thrives on heritage recipes, community ties, and word-of-mouth fame. From legendary pecan pies to hand-held fry pies, each establishment has its own unique charm and flavor palette. Explore eight of these hidden gems, known only to those who venture beyond the beaten path and dive into the rustic world of Ohio’s pie-making artistry.
1. Miller’s Bakery — Millersburg
Miller’s Bakery in Millersburg is a humble gem where bakes sell out quickly, much to the delight of early risers. This no-frills establishment attracts pie enthusiasts who know to come early or miss out. Each day, the aroma of fresh-baked goods wafts through the air, with fruit pies and apple fritters leading the charge. The bakery’s charm lies in its dedication to traditional techniques. A line out the door is not uncommon, as locals flock to grab their favorites before they’re gone. A visit here is a nostalgic nod to simpler times.
2. Kauffman’s Country Bakery — Millersburg
Just down the road in Millersburg, Kauffman’s Country Bakery is a destination for those seeking indulgence. The red-trimmed porch invites guests into a world of sugary delights. Massive cinnamon rolls and whoopie pies are among the offerings that have customers returning for more. However, it’s the sticky buns that steal the show, drawing people from miles around. The bakery’s ambiance is warm and welcoming, mirroring the friendly nature of its staff. Visitors often leave with a box full of assorted pastries, eager to savor each bite.
3. Amish Door Bakery — Wilmot
In the quaint village of Wilmot lies the Amish Door Bakery, a white building that seems like it’s straight out of a storybook. The charm of this bakery is as much in its appearance as it is in its pies. Homemade fry pies and cookies line the display, captivating visitors with their golden hues. This bakery thrives on traditional Amish recipes, cherished by locals who appreciate quality. It’s a must-visit for anyone who values baked goods crafted with love. The flower baskets outside add to the bakery’s visual appeal, making it Instagram-worthy.
4. Hershberger’s Farm & Bakery — Millersburg area
Nestled in the Millersburg area, Hershberger’s Farm & Bakery offers more than just pies—it’s an experience. With a working farm as its backdrop, this bakery is known for its fry pies, a local delicacy. These hand-held treats are filled with seasonal fruits and fried to golden perfection. The cream pies are equally tantalizing, showcasing the farm’s dedication to fresh ingredients. Visitors often find themselves immersed in the farm’s lively ambiance, enjoying the sights and sounds of rural life. It’s a place where tradition and community spirit thrive.
5. Dutch Valley Restaurant & Bakery — Sugarcreek
Sugarcreek’s Dutch Valley Restaurant & Bakery is a culinary retreat where comfort food reigns supreme. The bakery is famous for its peanut butter cream pies and fruit pies crowned with mile-high meringues. Each pie is a testament to Amish heritage, with recipes passed down through generations. Locals find solace in the familiar flavors, often returning for a taste of nostalgia. The cozy atmosphere invites patrons to linger, savoring each sweet bite. It’s a favorite stop for those seeking a hearty meal followed by homemade pie goodness.
6. Troyer’s Home Pantry — Apple Creek
Hidden in the small town of Apple Creek, Troyer’s Home Pantry is a mom-and-pop bakery that offers magical experiences with every visit. Known for their strawberry and pumpkin pies, this bakery is a hidden treasure. The enchanting display of pies beckons to passersby, promising a taste of tradition and warmth. Customers often describe the experience as magical, a delightful detour from the ordinary. It’s the kind of place where you pull over, linger, and savor the simple joys of life. Each pie is a slice of local heritage.
7. Walnut Creek Cheese bakery section — Walnut Creek
While Walnut Creek Cheese is known for its expansive market, its bakery section is a haven for sweet seekers. Silky peanut-butter pies and a variety of fruit pies tempt visitors after a hearty meal. The bustling energy of the market extends into the bakery, where locals satisfy their cravings with ease. It’s a go-to spot for those who appreciate well-crafted desserts. The pies here reflect a blend of creativity and tradition, making them a staple in the local community. Visitors often leave with a sweet reminder of their journey through Amish Country.
8. Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant — Berlin
Locals in Berlin, Ohio, find comfort in the simplicity of Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant. With pies that taste like home, this spot is a staple in Holmes County. Their fruit pies serve as a sweet reminder of the area’s rich agricultural ties. The pecan pie, often a conversation starter, is renowned for its buttery, flaky crust and rich filling. Regulars know they’re in the right place when they spot the Amish buggies parked out front. The restaurant’s down-to-earth ambiance makes it feel like a gathering place for the community.
