New Hampshire’s lobster roll scene is booming, offering some of the best crustacean delights that rival even the most renowned spots in Maine. From generous portions to unique flavors, these New Hampshire gems deliver a seafood experience that’s both delightful and unforgettable. Discover seven standout locations where lobster rolls are not just a dish, but a celebration.
1. Poor People’s Pub
At Poor People’s Pub in Sanbornville, lobster rolls are more than just a meal—they’re a sensation. Overflowing with succulent lobster meat, these rolls have earned the top spot in WMUR’s 2024 Viewers’ Choice. Patrons rave about the sheer volume of lobster, often needing a second roll to handle the generous portions.
The ambiance is as hearty as the food, with a rustic pub setting that invites laughter and camaraderie. This spot offers an experience that combines New England charm with culinary abundance. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, the pub’s lobster roll is a must-try that promises both quality and quantity.
Known for its warm and welcoming atmosphere, Poor People’s Pub ensures each visit is memorable.
2. The Beach Plum
The Beach Plum is a beloved choice for lobster enthusiasts across multiple New Hampshire locations. Known for its generously stuffed lobster rolls, this eatery offers great value and quality. Ranked #2 in WMUR’s 2024 list, The Beach Plum is often celebrated for its options in roll sizes, ranging from 4 oz to 10 oz, catering to all appetites.
Beyond lobster, the place attracts families with its incredible variety of 78 ice cream flavors, making it a perfect summer treat destination.
Whether you’re at Epping, Portsmouth, North Hampton, or Salem, this seaside eatery provides a consistent and delightful experience that keeps seafood lovers returning for more.
3. Tuckaway Tavern & Butchery
Tuckaway Tavern & Butchery in Raymond offers a unique twist on the classic lobster roll experience, especially with their buy-one-get-one-free offer on Mondays and Tuesdays. Ranked #3 in WMUR’s 2024 list, this spot is a favorite among those looking to double their enjoyment without doubling the cost.
The lively atmosphere of the tavern complements its hearty meals, with patrons enjoying both the food and the friendly service.
This establishment not only delivers on taste but also on value, making it a staple for both locals and visiting seafood lovers. The tavern’s reputation for quality and generosity makes it a culinary gem in New Hampshire.
4. Rye Harbor Lobster Pound
Nestled by the ocean in Rye, Rye Harbor Lobster Pound offers a quintessential New England seafood experience. Ranked #4 in WMUR’s list, the shack is adored for its hot, buttered lobster rolls served on perfectly grilled buns.
The setting is simple yet charming, capturing the essence of coastal dining with every bite. The taste of fresh lobster paired with the sea breeze creates a moment of pure culinary bliss.
For those seeking a true taste of the sea, Rye Harbor Lobster Pound delivers an authentic and satisfying meal. Its small, seasonal operation ensures each roll is fresh and flavorful, making it a must-visit for seafood aficionados.
5. Petey’s Summertime Seafood & Bar
Petey’s Summertime Seafood & Bar, located in Rye, stands out for its fresh catches and inviting beachfront vibes. Ranked #5 in WMUR’s lineup, it offers both regular and jumbo cold lobster rolls that seafood lovers can’t resist. The fresh, tender lobster meat paired with the cool ocean breeze creates an unforgettable dining experience.
The beachside bar atmosphere is lively and welcoming, often filled with laughter and the clinking of glasses. Known for its extensive seafood menu, Petey’s attracts both locals and tourists with its charm and quality.
Whether you’re looking for a casual bite or a seafood feast, Petey’s provides a perfect setting for sunny days and fresh flavors.
6. Brown’s Lobster Pound
Brown’s Lobster Pound in Seabrook is a cherished family-run establishment steeped in tradition. Known for its old-school charm, it has been serving up classics since 1950. This spot is loved for offering traditional lobster shack vibes, with boiled lobster, creamy chowder, and classic rolls that capture the heart of New England dining.
The warm, nostalgic atmosphere invites patrons to enjoy meals that feel both comforting and authentic. The long-standing reputation of Brown’s as a staple among lobster shacks ensures a consistent quality that keeps diners coming back.
Experience the timeless appeal of a genuine lobster pound where every meal is made with love and history.
7. Markey’s Lobster Pool
Markey’s Lobster Pool, located directly across from Brown’s in Seabrook, offers a lively counterpart in the local seafood scene. This long-standing rival, operating since 1971, provides a similar classic menu that features fresh lobster rolls and seafood delights.
The friendly rivalry creates an exciting atmosphere where patrons can sample and compare offerings from both establishments. Known for its relaxed setting, Markey’s offers a delightful escape where you can savor the flavors of the sea.
With its reputation for quality, Markey’s continues to be a beloved choice for those seeking an authentic New England lobster roll experience. The unique dynamic between these two seafood spots adds to the charm of visiting Seabrook.
