Indiana is home to some of the most cherished pie shops where recipes and customer loyalty have been passed down through generations. This list highlights ten beloved pie establishments, each offering unique flavors and a slice of Indiana’s rich culinary history.
1. Wick’s Pie (Winchester)
Wick’s Pie, nestled in Winchester, Indiana, is a testament to Hoosier heritage, serving delight since 1944. Known for its legendary Sugar Cream Pie, affectionately termed “Hoosier Pie,” the bakery crafts thousands daily, maintaining a commitment to quality that spans over six decades. The familial warmth felt here is as comforting as their pies, making it a nostalgic stop for many.
Stepping into Wick’s is like stepping back in time. The decor whispers stories of generations, with vintage charm accentuating the pies’ appeal. Each creation is a beacon of tradition, reflecting meticulous care and time-honored recipes. Locals and travelers alike are drawn to this iconic establishment, eager to taste a piece of Indiana’s rich history.
Fun fact: Wick’s production scale is impressive, churning out over 12,000 pies daily, yet they maintain the same dedication to quality that began with their very first pie.
2. Generations Pie Company (Fortville)
Generations Pie Company in Fortville, Indiana, is more than a bakery—it’s a tribute to family legacy. Founded by Maria Johnson in 2016, it honors familial ties with pies named after recipe originators like “Grandma Hattie Leota’s Sweet Apple Pie” and “Winston’s Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie.” This shop is a haven for those who appreciate the stories behind the flavors.
The aroma of freshly baked pies welcomes you, creating a cozy atmosphere filled with warmth and laughter. Each pie tells a story, connecting the past to the present through taste and tradition. It’s a place where memories are baked into every crust.
Did you know? Generations Pie Company is set to open a new café adjacent to their bakery, promising even more heartfelt flavors and stories. This expansion signifies not just growth, but a continued commitment to celebrate family through food.
3. My Sugar Pie (Zionsville)
In the heart of Zionsville, Indiana, My Sugar Pie stands as a beacon for pie lovers. Renowned for its pumpkin pie, this charming spot offers some of Indiana’s most cherished flavors. The shop prides itself on delivering “greatest pies known to man,” a bold claim backed by countless satisfied patrons.
The interior of My Sugar Pie is inviting, with an ambiance that feels both homey and elegant. Each pie is a masterpiece, crafted with care and passion that’s palpable in every slice. The shop is not merely a place to buy pies; it’s a destination where memories are made.
Fun trivia: My Sugar Pie has been a beloved part of the local community for over a decade, with their pies often being the highlight of holiday celebrations. Their commitment to quality and flavor keeps customers returning, year after year.
4. Gray Brothers Cafeteria (Mooresville)
Gray Brothers Cafeteria in Mooresville is a culinary institution. This family-owned eatery is famous for its cafeteria-style dining and an impressive array of house-baked pies. Around holidays, locals queue up for a taste of their rhubarb, coconut, and other delectable pies.
The atmosphere is lively, with the buzz of happy diners filling the air. Each pie is a testament to the cafeteria’s steadfast dedication to quality and flavor. For many, a visit here is a cherished tradition, passed down through generations.
Interesting fact: Every Wednesday, diners can enjoy a free slice of pie with their meal, a tradition that has endeared Gray Brothers to the community. This small gesture of hospitality encapsulates the warmth and generosity that defines Indiana’s culinary scene.
5. Clifty Inn (Madison)
Nestled near the scenic Clifty Falls State Park, Clifty Inn in Madison offers not just a place to rest but a culinary delight. Known for serving the “Best Peanut Butter Pie in Indiana,” this inn is a favorite among both travelers and locals.
The inn’s dining area is cozy, with views that mirror the allure of the outdoors. Each pie is a decadent creation, rich in flavor and history. It’s the perfect sweet treat after exploring the park, making your visit to Clifty Inn all the more memorable.
Did you know? The Clifty Inn was part of a statewide pie contest that crowned their Peanut Butter Pie as the best, cementing their status in Indiana’s dessert scene. This accolade draws pie lovers from far and wide, eager to experience its unparalleled taste.
6. Lisa’s Pie Shop (Atlanta, IN)
Lisa’s Pie Shop, located in the quaint town of Atlanta, Indiana, promises an adventure in every bite. Known for its award-winning pies and innovative “pie in a jar,” visitors flock here for a taste of nostalgia. The shop, a staple on pie road trips, draws pie enthusiasts eager to enjoy its homestyle flavors.
Step inside to discover a world of delightful confections, each pie crafted with love and precision. The shop’s charm is undeniable, with a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel part of the family. It’s not just about the pies; it’s the experience of savoring a tradition that has been lovingly preserved.
Interesting tidbit: Lisa’s Pie Shop has garnered numerous accolades for its unique approach, including being featured in several national publications. Their inventive “pie in a jar” concept allows you to take a piece of Indiana with you wherever you go.
7. Olde Richmond Inn (Richmond)
Richmond’s Olde Richmond Inn is a haven for those seeking a touch of elegance with their dessert. Celebrated for its Peanut Butter Pie, this historic inn combines charm with culinary excellence. The inn’s ambiance is refined yet welcoming, providing a perfect setting for indulging in one of Indiana’s best desserts.
Each slice of pie is a testament to the inn’s legacy of quality and flavor. The attention to detail in its preparation makes every bite a delightful experience, drawing patrons from all over.
Fun fact: Olde Richmond Inn has been recognized as part of Indiana’s “Best Pie” honors, a testament to its enduring popularity and the exceptional quality of its pies. This accolade ensures that their pies are always in high demand, with loyal customers returning time and again.
8. Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery (Shipshewana)
In the heart of Indiana’s Amish country, Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery in Shipshewana offers a slice of tradition with every dessert. Renowned for its Northern Indiana favorite, Berry Pie, this bakery is a staple for those seeking hearty, homemade flavors.
The atmosphere is warm and inviting, echoing the simplicity and wholesomeness of Amish culture. Each pie is a reflection of the rich traditions and craftsmanship that define this region.
Did you know? Blue Gate’s Berry Pie is a beloved choice, made from recipes passed down through generations. This dedication to preserving culinary heritage makes it a must-visit for pie enthusiasts exploring Indiana’s diverse flavors.
9. Amish Acres (Nappanee)
Amish Acres in Nappanee offers not just a taste of pie, but a journey into Amish tradition. Known for its Shoo-Fly and Pumpkin pies, this destination provides a rich immersion into a culture where baking is a cherished art.
Visitors are greeted with a warm atmosphere, where the scent of freshly baked goods fills the air. Each pie tells a story of heritage and craftsmanship, inviting guests to savor the simplicity and richness of Amish baking.
Interesting tidbit: Amish Acres is a cultural landmark, offering not just pies but an experience that includes tours and traditional Amish events. It’s a destination where history and flavor combine, making it a memorable stop for those exploring Indiana’s culinary landscape.
10. Abe Martin Lodge (Brown County State Park, Nashville)
Amidst the natural beauty of Brown County State Park, Abe Martin Lodge in Nashville offers a sweet retreat with its mini Peanut Butter Pies. This rustic lodge provides a cozy escape from the hustle and bustle, with desserts that reflect the serenity of its surroundings.
The lodge’s setting enhances the pie experience, making each bite a moment of tranquility. Visitors often enjoy these pies after a day exploring the park, finding them the perfect end to an adventure in nature.
Did you know? Abe Martin Lodge’s mini Peanut Butter Pies have become a beloved tradition, offering a unique twist on a classic favorite. Their small size packs a punch of flavor, ensuring they’re a hit with both locals and visitors alike.
